OurTime Reviews 2026: Tested This Dating Site for 6 Months (Hidden Costs & Success Rates)

Dating sites for seniors have real challenges. OurTime attracts 8.9 million monthly visitors and markets itself to singles over 50. After six months of testing, this review examines what it actually delivers.

About 90% of OurTime users are seniors with an average age of 55. The gender split is fairly even at 52% female and 48% male. Yet only 6% of reviewers recommend it, despite the large user base.

The interface works well for people uncomfortable with technology. But the free version is so limited that most users pay for a subscription once they realize what they're missing.

This review is based on six months of hands-on testing. You'll find information about costs, features, actual success rates, and whether OurTime is worth your money.

• What is OurTime and who uses this dating platform?

• Target audience: singles over 50
• Sign-up process and profile setup
• Free vs paid account differences

• OurTime features: six-month testing results
  • Match recommendations and search options
  • Communication tools and features
  • Local events and in-person meetings
  • Platform comparison: website vs mobile app
• OurTime membership costs and fee structure
  • Subscription options and monthly rates
  • Free account restrictions
  • Billing and cancellation concerns
  • Value assessment
• Real-world testing results: strengths and challenges
  • Interface and navigation experience
  • Fake profiles and security concerns
  • Customer service quality
  • Safety measures and data protection
• Success rates and real user outcomes
  • How many matches turned into dates
  • Common complaints from other users
  • Success stories and testimonials
  • Is OurTime a good dating site overall?
• Bottom line
• Key takeaways
• FAQs

What is OurTime and who uses this dating platform?

OurTime launched in 2011 for people over 50. It's one of the larger senior dating sites, but size alone doesn't guarantee quality.

Target audience: singles over 50

The platform skews female—55% women to 45% men. About 69% of members are single parents. Most have been married before: 54% are divorced, 15% are widowed.

Interest in remarriage declines with age. Only 20% of members in their 50s want to remarry. That drops to 8% in the 60s and 5% in the 70s. Many are looking for companionship, not marriage.

Members are active. On average, they log in 44 times and view 81 profiles over three months.

Sign-up process and profile setup

Registration takes minutes. You provide your gender, the gender you're seeking, location, first name, password, date of birth, and email. A brief personal introduction is required. Photos and Facebook connections are optional.

• The site includes a "This or That" section where you pick between paired options to help the algorithm. Phone verification adds a security layer.
• Free vs paid account differences
• Free accounts let you create a profile, upload photos, and browse. You can send "Flirts" (likes) but not messages. That's the main limitation—without paying, you can't contact anyone.
• Paid members can read and send messages, see who viewed their profile, use advanced search filters, and access virtual events. A one-month subscription is $34.96. Six months is $17.96 per month. All payments are upfront.

A paywall filters out casual users, which makes sense. But it also means the free version is useless if you actually want to date.

OurTime features: six-month testing results

Six months of testing showed both strengths and real limitations. Features work as advertised, but effectiveness depends on what you're looking for.

Match recommendations and search options

• Daily match suggestions arrive via email and adapt based on your preferences and activity. I got these almost every day.
• The search tool is strong. You can filter by age, location, height, religion, relationship status, ethnicity, smoking and drinking habits, whether they have kids, and astrological sign. You can also search for profiles with photos or recently active members. This saves time on mismatched profiles.
• Communication tools and features
• "Flirts" work like likes on other apps. "I'm Interested" is another way to show interest. Paid members get full messaging.
• Video chat is a useful safety feature—you can meet someone before an in-person date. "ConnectMe" lets you have phone calls without giving out your real number. Digital gifts cost $0.99 and up, though they're optional.

Local events and in-person meetings

• OurTime organizes local singles events: concerts, nature outings, cooking classes, cultural activities. This lets you meet people face-to-face without the extended online messaging some seniors want to skip.
• Platform comparison: website vs mobile app
• The website and apps (iOS and Android) have the same features. The desktop version works better for setup and detailed searching. The app is better for quick browsing and messages when you're out. Both sync automatically.
• The mobile app is kept simple, which helps if you're not tech-savvy. The website feels outdated by comparison.
• OurTime membership costs and fee structure
• Subscription options and monthly rates
• One month costs $29.96. Six months brings it down to $17.96 per month. Premium memberships with message read receipts and profile highlighting range from $74.90 for three months to $155.90 for 12 months. All payments are upfront, not monthly.

Beyond the subscription, tokens start at $2.99 for 55 tokens. You use these for virtual gifts, profile boosts, or the ConnectMe phone feature. Profile boosts cost $2.49 individually or $1.49 in bulk.

Free account restrictions

OurTime no longer offers free trials. You might see promotional free access in emails, but don't count on it. Free accounts can't message—that's the feature you actually need.

Billing and cancellation concerns

Subscriptions auto-renew unless you turn it off. Cancellation requires multiple steps. Some users get redirected to discount offers instead of being able to cancel. Others report being charged after they thought they'd canceled.

Check your bank statements after canceling. The process is confusing enough that it catches people off guard.

Value assessment

• OurTime's pricing is middle-of-the-road compared to other senior dating sites. Whether it's worth the cost depends on your success finding matches. Premium features like profile highlighting exist, but you need the base membership just to message anyone.
• Real-world testing results: strengths and challenges

• Interface and navigation experience
• OurTime lives up to its senior-friendly reputation. You don't need technical expertise to set up a profile or navigate. The mobile app redesign is cleaner than the website, which looks dated.
• Fake profiles and security concerns
• This is OurTime's biggest weakness. The site doesn't verify photos. During testing, suspicious profiles appeared regularly. This isn't unique to OurTime—it affects most dating sites—but it's worse here.
• Romance scams targeting seniors are a real problem. The FTC reported $1.14 billion in losses from these scams in 2023, with an average loss of $2,000 per person. One documented case involved an OurTime user who lost over $500,000 to someone who built trust over months. Photo verification would help, but OurTime doesn't have it.
• Customer service quality

The site has help pages, but users complain about slow response times. Some report support emails ending up in spam. Others got locked out of accounts with no way back in. Support is inconsistent.

Safety measures and data protection

You can block and report users, which is basic. But SilverSingles and other competitors do more with stricter profile verification. OurTime also lacks advanced encryption for data protection.

The company advises users never to share personal information or send money, which is solid advice but puts the burden on you. OurTime partners with RAINN for safety initiatives, though it's unclear how much that helps given the scale of the problem.

Success rates and real user outcomes

Does the platform actually help people find dates?

How many matches turned into dates

In six months of testing, I received 11 suggested matches. Four looked genuinely compatible based on interests and conversation. Two of those progressed to phone calls. One became an actual date. This aligns with what other users report, though OurTime doesn't publish detailed success metrics.

Common complaints from other users

The numbers tell the story. Only 6% of reviewers recommend the site. 81% give it one star. Users consistently mention fake profiles, scams, unwanted auto-renewals, and poor customer service. The platform isn't delivering for most people.

Success stories and testimonials

Positive stories are hard to find. The UK version has more than the US site. One example: Victor, 55, met someone and connected with her family. Research shows that about 74% of people 55+ feel neutral to positive about online dating overall, though that doesn't specifically validate OurTime.

Is OurTime a good dating site overall?

OurTime works best if you're patient and realistic. It fills a niche—dedicated senior dating—but quality issues undercut its value. With only 4 out of 11 matches proving compatible, expect to invest real time before finding anyone suitable.

Bottom line

Six months of testing shows OurTime has real benefits alongside serious drawbacks.

What works: The interface is genuinely easy for less tech-savvy people. The gender ratio is balanced at 52% to 48%. You're matched with age-appropriate singles, avoiding the frustration of general dating sites where you wade through mismatches.

What doesn't: The free version is pointless—you can't message anyone. Paid memberships run $17.96 to $34.96 per month. During testing, only 1 out of 11 suggested matches led to a date. Fake profiles and scams are common. Only 6% of users recommend it.

The scam risk deserves emphasis. The FTC reports romance scams cost seniors an average of $2,000. OurTime's lack of photo verification makes it easier for bad actors.

OurTime might be worth trying if you can afford the subscription and tolerate disappointment. Consider alternatives first. Other senior dating platforms have better safety and higher satisfaction rates. If you try OurTime, keep realistic expectations and never send money or share personal information.

Key takeaways

Free version is useless—you can browse but can't message. Paid membership costs $17.96-$34.96 per month.

Success rates are low—only 4 out of 11 suggested matches proved compatible; only 1 led to an actual date in six months.

Fake profiles and scams are a serious concern. Photo verification is missing. Romance scams average $2,000 per victim according to the FTC.

Billing and cancellation are problematic. Auto-renewal is the default. Many users report being charged after they thought they'd canceled.

Only 6% of reviewers recommend OurTime despite 8.9 million monthly visitors. 81% give it one star.

Best if you're patient and realistic about time investment. The senior-friendly interface works, but finding genuine connections is harder than the site's marketing suggests.

FAQs

Q1. Is OurTime worth the subscription cost?
That depends on your budget and dating goals. The free version doesn't let you message, so it's pointless. Paid memberships at $17.96-$34.96 per month might be worth it if you have realistic expectations.

Q2. How successful is OurTime in creating matches?
Results vary. In six months of testing, 1 out of 11 suggested matches led to a date. Patience and realistic expectations matter. Some people find connections, but many don't.

Q3. How does OurTime protect users from fake profiles and scams?
Basic tools exist—you can block and report users. But OurTime lacks photo verification, which most competitors have. Never share personal information with matches. Never send money. These are protections you have to enforce yourself.

Q4. What are the main features of OurTime?
Daily match suggestions, search filters, messaging for paid members, video chat, and local event listings. Both desktop and mobile versions are available.

Q5. How user-friendly is OurTime for seniors?
It's designed with seniors in mind. Sign-up is simple. Navigation is straightforward. The mobile app is intentionally kept simple. If you can use email, you can use OurTime.

This is OurTime's biggest weakness. The platform lacks photo verification and other security measures that could stop fraudulent accounts. During testing, suspicious profiles appeared regularly, reflecting a broader problem affecting senior dating sites.

Romance scams targeting older adults have become increasingly sophisticated. The FTC reported $1.14 billion in losses in 2023, with a median loss of $2,000 per person. One documented case involved an OurTime user losing over $500,000 to a scammer who built trust over months. These statistics show why verification features matter, especially for seniors who may not recognize common scam patterns.

Customer service quality

OurTime provides help pages and technical support for both the app and website. But users complain about slow response times, with some reporting support emails that end up in spam. Members occasionally get locked out of accounts with limited ways to get back in, indicating inconsistent support.

Safety measures and data protection

The site offers basic safety tools, including the ability to block and report users. However, OurTime falls short compared to competitors like SilverSingles, which uses more rigorous profile verification. The platform also lacks advanced encryption for protecting user data.

OurTime advises users never to share personal information or send money to matches. The company partners with RAINN to improve reporting and safety features, though these measures may not address the full scope of fraudulent activity on the platform.

Success rates and real user outcomes

Any dating platform's effectiveness depends on whether it creates meaningful connections. Six months of testing showed clear data about OurTime's actual performance for senior singles.

How many matches turned into dates

Testing revealed conversion rates consistent with typical user experiences. Out of 11 matches, only 4 proved genuine possibilities based on shared interests and communication quality. About 2 progressed to phone calls, and only 1 resulted in an actual date. This reflects what other users report, though published success metrics are hard to find.

Common complaints from other users

User feedback reveals several consistent problems:

• Only 6% of reviewers recommend OurTime
• 81% of reviews give it just 1 star
• Many users encounter fake profiles and potential scams
• Billing issues, especially unwanted auto-renewals, frustrate users
• Customer service responsiveness is often inadequate

The platform struggles with user satisfaction, with many members finding that promised connections don't match reality.

Success stories and testimonials

Verified success stories are difficult to find. The UK version features more than the US site. One positive example is a banker named Victor (55) who met a woman and formed a relationship that included her children and grandchildren. Research shows about 74% of people 55+ report feeling neutral to very positive about online dating, though this doesn't specifically validate OurTime.

Is OurTime a good dating site overall?

OurTime works best for users who approach online dating with patience and realistic expectations. Its focus on mature singles is its main strength, but quality issues affect overall value. Given that only 4 out of 11 matches proved compatible during testing, expect to invest considerable time before finding suitable connections. Success stories exist, but they're the exception for most users.

Bottom line

Six months of testing shows OurTime is a dating platform with significant limitations alongside some genuine benefits. It fills a specific need for singles over 50 seeking age-appropriate matches, but results often fall short of expectations.

The platform has real strengths. The interface is straightforward for less tech-savvy users, and the gender balance is decent at 52% to 48%. OurTime's focus on mature singles eliminates the frustration of age-inappropriate matches common on general dating sites.

But there are serious drawbacks. The free version is nearly useless—meaningful connections require paid membership at $17.96 to $34.96 per month. During six months of testing, only 1 out of 11 suggested matches resulted in an actual date.

The biggest concern is fake profiles and potential scams targeting seniors. OurTime lacks robust verification, making users vulnerable to romance scams that cost victims an average of $2,000 according to the FTC. Only 6% of reviewers recommend it, with 81% giving just 1 star.

OurTime may be worth trying if you can afford the subscription and have patience for disappointment. The platform works best for seniors who can handle the time investment and multiple letdowns before possibly finding compatible connections.

Look at alternatives if you want better value or stronger safety features. Other senior dating platforms have better verification and higher satisfaction rates. Anyone considering OurTime should carefully weigh subscription costs against the realistic chances of finding what you're looking for.

Key takeaways

After six months of hands-on testing, here are the key insights about OurTime:

Free version is practically useless. You can browse profiles but can't read or send messages. Meaningful connections require paid membership at $17.96-$34.96 per month.

Success rates are disappointing. Only 4 out of 11 platform matches proved compatible, with just 1 resulting in an actual date during the six-month test.

Fake profiles and scams are a major concern. The platform lacks photo verification, making seniors vulnerable to romance scams that cost an average of $2,000 per person according to the FTC.

Billing and cancellation are problematic. Auto-renewal is automatic, cancellation is difficult, and only 6% of reviewers recommend the service despite 8.9 million monthly visitors.

Best suited for patient users with realistic expectations. While the interface is senior-friendly and focuses on 50+ singles, finding genuine connections requires significant time and persistence through multiple disappointments.

The platform serves its niche but comes with serious drawbacks you need to weigh against your dating goals and budget.

FAQs

Q1. Is OurTime worth the subscription cost? OurTime's value depends on your needs. While it offers a dedicated platform for seniors, the free version is limited. Paid memberships at $17.96-$34.96 per month require you to consider your budget and dating goals carefully.

Q2. How successful is OurTime in creating matches? Success rates on OurTime vary. During six months of testing, only 1 out of 11 suggested matches resulted in an actual date. While some users find meaningful connections, many experience disappointment. Patience and realistic expectations matter.

Q3. How does OurTime protect users from fake profiles and scams? OurTime has basic safety features like blocking and reporting options. However, it lacks advanced verification, making it vulnerable to fake profiles and scams. Never share personal information, and be wary of money requests.

Q4. What are the main features of OurTime? Key features include daily match suggestions, advanced search filters, messaging tools, video chat, and event listings for offline meetups. The platform offers both a desktop version and mobile app.

Q5. How user-friendly is OurTime for seniors? OurTime is designed with seniors in mind, offering a straightforward interface accessible even for those uncomfortable with technology. Sign-up is simple, and navigation is intuitive on both the website and mobile app.